I don't see much of a problem with the overview since it is on a separate page. Ideally a good slideshow is what would give the quick overview of what the game is. I do prefer the new color scheme personally, partially because the forums are blue. It is just such a huge change going between the current page and the forums. If the forums matched the current page it would not be as big of a deal.Spunkmeyer wrote:QUOTE (Spunkmeyer @ Aug 5 2012, 11:19 AM) I somewhat disagree. I agree with your bullet points that follow, however the new design also has its issues. The "sci-fi" header font is seriously unreadable. It also manages to be even more text-heavy than the current page: when I get to the current page I instantly get a good quick overview of what the game is. With the new page, I have to click on the overview button and run into a wall-of-text. Finally the color scheme of the new page, while may be more space-oriented, is a lot more common and doesn't stand out as much as the current one.
(I've already voiced most of this to SpaceJunk when he first produced the design, but from his "$#@! off" response back then I figure he is not interested in producing variations.)
All that IMHO of course, and is not why the new design was not implemented/considered. That's probably more to do with TE not having time for anything. But I just don't see it as much of a design improvement over the current one, SEO issues aside.
The big advantages though of that page are:
Multiple pages - It would be good to have more information accessible from the home page and it will help us greatly with SEO.News/blogs - I like how news is implemented, again assuming Google sees it. I do not really care for blogs on the front page. However, Google does prefer fresh content so it helps SEO. We should try to avoid a static homepage and listing blogs (assuming we have some active ones...) helps it stay fresh.Slideshow - Debatable, but I generally prefer slideshows on a homepage over a video. Video is best on a separate page like it is with the new design.






