Weird Question

Non-Allegiance related. High probability of spam. Pruned regularly.
Malicious Wraith
Posts: 3170
Joined: Sun Jul 16, 2006 12:51 am

Post by Malicious Wraith »

MrChaos wrote:QUOTE (MrChaos @ Feb 14 2015, 10:05 AM) The problem originated with your inability to ask the question you wanted answered.
Yep. To me, its just a weird ice thing.

But the answers here were more than sufficient to titillate my laymen's mind.
Last edited by Malicious Wraith on Sun Feb 15, 2015 8:33 am, edited 1 time in total.
Unknown wrote:[Just want] to play some games before Alleg dies for good.
I don't want that time to be a @#(!-storm of hate and schadenfreude.
IG: Liquid_Mamba / Fedman
MrChaos
Posts: 8352
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 8:00 am

Post by MrChaos »

The water froze in your bottle most likely froze this way:

Asumming that it froze while the car was stationary
The cooling occurred via conductive cooling between the bottle's walls and the water
The air in the bottle's convective currents were mild ( an important assumption ) as the volume was small and the air was surrounded on all sides by (relatively) uniform cooling
If the bottle was in the shade and/or it was night the effects of radiation would be negligible

Air is an awesome insulator and in a free convection state (as I described) would play only a small (almost no is my guess) role in the cooling process. The freezing would intiate via conduction. So the ice forms on the boundary between the water bottle and the water moving inward toward the center. Eventually the water will reach the freezing point in other locations and as long as there is stuff to allow ice to form, ice will begin to form elsewherr. Given the system we are discussing it very well could form in the middle depending circumstances. Once it forms the now lower density ice will move upward due to bouncy forces unless adhering to other bits of ice or the bottle surface ( why and how is beyond my rudimentary understanding ).

Ice cube trays freeze differently fwiw because convection now plays a much stronger role. How much is occurring is dependent on a variety of factors. If the tray is sitting on the freezer surface or suspended above another tray matters too. My guess is the cube freezes in the center last generally because of convective currents in the water.

How water freezes in a lake is more comp located due to the endless variabless of course and initially what I thought you were ultimately after with your question.

DuscanC I have a smart phone and am forcing myself to use swype and editing along with small screen, sick eyes, lack of patience for correcting its learning assumptions... and spooling of course lead to your frustrations ;)

edit: I am not an expert on ice formation and ran no model or experiment. Errors left in to annoy DuscanC ;)
Last edited by MrChaos on Tue Feb 17, 2015 12:16 am, edited 1 time in total.
Ssssh
KingJoffrey
Posts: 41
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2015 1:56 pm

Post by KingJoffrey »

KING OBSERVES LACK OF COMPETENCY OF PHOENIX1 AND MRC COMBINED. ANY OPEN WATER BODY ICE CUBES INCLUDED PRIMARILY FREEZES DUE TO EVAPORATION AT THE SURFACE ASSUMING POORLY CONDUCTING TRAY.


ICE ADHERES TO SURFACES OF BOTTLES AND DOES NOT FLOAT AS THE ICE DENDRITES ARE TINY AND ACT IN EFFECT AS GLUE EXPLOITING ANY SURFACE IMPERFECTION. IF YOU HAVE NO SURFACE IMPERFECTIONS THEN YOU SUPERCOOL WATER AND GET ONE GIANT ICE CRYSTAL AT ANY NUCLEATION SITE RANDOMLY SPONTANEOUSLY.
raumvogel
Posts: 5910
Joined: Sun Jul 20, 2003 7:00 am
Location: My lawn
Contact:

Post by raumvogel »

I know it's not on topic........





.....but my Elzam detector just wen't off.
Image
lexaal
Posts: 2612
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 12:58 pm

Post by lexaal »

I wonder/ would like to know:
-if volume changing effects(=movement) at the moment of freezin are relevant or can be ignored completely.
-why convection get more relevant for ice cubes compared to bottle (smaller volume --> higher damping trough wall friction --> less convection in my theory)
-how much is typical undercooling of normal and distilled water? We made some measures at university but usually our temp sensor was the "freezing seed"
-if the PDE which is (with cooling) a highly nonlinear ("reaction*") diffusion convection nighmare is solvable.
-(slightly off-topic): I read that full freezers require less energy than empty freezers... but since interiour temperature is regulated(= constant) the surface and temperature both difference don't change...so why?
-why do some people on the internet still say hot liquids are frozen faster than cold liquids?

Kingjoffrey: Often(Always?) ice cube trays have covers s.t. half of the water is not at the wall of your freezer afterwards. Have no doubt in MrC's competence and knowledge of modern cooling equipment.

*The nerd in me assumes that freezing can and should be modelled similar to a chemical two-way reaction.
I have a johnson photo in my profile since 2010.
zombywoof
Posts: 6523
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2008 4:59 am
Location: Over the Rainbow

Post by zombywoof »

raumvogel wrote:QUOTE (raumvogel @ Feb 16 2015, 07:30 PM) I know it's not on topic........





.....but my Elzam detector just wen't off.
Oh Noodle is definitely Elzam. Completely obnoxious in game and out, marginally competent at whatever he's trying to say or do at best... the only question is how P32 can stand the $#@!er.
lexaal wrote:QUOTE (lexaal @ Feb 18 2015, 12:24 PM) I wonder/ would like to know:
-if volume changing effects(=movement) at the moment of freezin are relevant or can be ignored completely.
-why convection get more relevant for ice cubes compared to bottle (smaller volume --> higher damping trough wall friction --> less convection in my theory)
-how much is typical undercooling of normal and distilled water? We made some measures at university but usually our temp sensor was the "freezing seed"
-if the PDE which is (with cooling) a highly nonlinear ("reaction*") diffusion convection nighmare is solvable.
-(slightly off-topic): I read that full freezers require less energy than empty freezers... but since interiour temperature is regulated(= constant) the surface and temperature both difference don't change...so why?
-why do some people on the internet still say hot liquids are frozen faster than cold liquids?
-Yes, volume changing effects would be relevant if they were sufficient. While liquids aren't ideal gasses by a long shot (only being somewhat compressible), it's still generally true that by compressing a body of water you'll increase the latent heat in it. After all, by compressing the water you're doing work on it ;)

-It's the convection of the air around it which is relevant rather than the convection in the water. Water's convection isn't particularly relevant towards how the ice forms insofar as where the ice forms. It's still going to form in shallow areas that are exposed to convecting or strong conducting effects. What convection in the water *does* change is which specific water molecules freeze at what particular point but... meh.

-about 50C or so below 0 for purified water. Other than that, "normal" water is going to need a better definition :P Depends on what's in your wells.

-Couldn't tell you. I suspect it is but also not worth solving.

-The reason full freezers take less energy to run is because there's more *stuff* in a full freezer. that might not make a whole lot of sense, but remember that temperature is a measurement of the average kinetic energy of every particle. In an "empty" freezer, this is a relatively small bit of gas. In a freezer stocked to the gills with frozen fish sticks and ice-cream, there's a lot more *stuff* in there. So if you add a small amount of energy (because it leaks in through the freezer's insulation, for example) it doesn't raise the internal temperature by all that much.

-Because there are a lot of morons on the internet. It's actually not a particularly unintuitive effect if you understand what "hot water freezes faster than cold" is actually saying. Here's a quick primer I found:

http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/General/hot_water.html

Basically the gist of it is, we're assuming that we have two equal volumes of water at different temperatures. Unfortunately we can't control important other things like the gas content of the water and the convection currents might end up slightly different in each of them. In this case we're more accurately comparing apples and pears than red apples and green apples.
Image
Don't find fault, find a remedy; anybody can complain.
Cookie Monster wrote:QUOTE (Cookie Monster @ Apr 1 2009, 09:35 PM) But I don't read the forums I only post.
KingJoffrey
Posts: 41
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2015 1:56 pm

Post by KingJoffrey »

phoenix1 wrote:QUOTE (phoenix1 @ Feb 18 2015, 06:19 PM) Oh Noodle is definitely Elzam. Completely obnoxious in game and out, marginally competent at whatever he's trying to say or do at best...

Says the guy who has no clue bout game mechanics and completely fails at physics and reading comprehension.

- The volume change refers to water>ice volume change not compressibility. Comparing water to an ideal gas is like comparing vacuum to your brain mass

- Oh $#@! why I bother: full freezer has higher thermal mass but still same energy loss = same running costs.

King is reminded of Adept when he is reading P1 drivel. Unlike P1 Adept was right once in a blue moon.
Last edited by KingJoffrey on Wed Feb 18, 2015 11:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
cashto
Posts: 3165
Joined: Mon Sep 10, 2007 5:40 am
Location: Seattle

Post by cashto »

phoenix1 wrote:QUOTE (phoenix1 @ Feb 18 2015, 02:19 PM) Oh Noodle is definitely Elzam. Completely obnoxious in game and out, marginally competent at whatever he's trying to say or do at best... the only question is how P32 can stand the $#@!er.
I presume this is sarcasm ...
Globemaster_III wrote:QUOTE (Globemaster_III @ Jan 11 2018, 11:27 PM) as you know i think very little of cashto, cashto alway a flying low pilot, he alway flying a trainer airplane and he rented
Malicious Wraith
Posts: 3170
Joined: Sun Jul 16, 2006 12:51 am

Post by Malicious Wraith »

Free Allegiance forums:
Ask a question about ice in a bottle, thread becomes solely personal attacks before the second page is reached.
Unknown wrote:[Just want] to play some games before Alleg dies for good.
I don't want that time to be a @#(!-storm of hate and schadenfreude.
IG: Liquid_Mamba / Fedman
Raveen
Posts: 9104
Joined: Wed Mar 16, 2005 8:00 am
Location: Birmingham, UK
Contact:

Post by Raveen »

Malicious Wraith wrote:QUOTE (Malicious Wraith @ Feb 19 2015, 06:00 AM) The Internet
Ask a question about ice in a bottle, thread becomes solely personal attacks before the second page is reached.
FTFY
ImageImage
Spidey: Can't think of a reason I'd need to know anything
Post Reply